Employer Hiring Guide

How to Hire a Business Development Manager Who Can Build Pipeline and Win New Business

A strong BDM hire is not simply someone who interviews well or has held the title before. Define the role around the market, customer, sales cycle and the new-business outcomes the person actually needs to create.

The Short Answer

To hire a strong Business Development Manager, first define how new business is expected to be created. Then assess candidates against evidence of prospecting, pipeline creation, qualification, opportunity progression and closing in a comparable sales environment.

01 · Define The Role

Start with the sales outcome, not the job title.

“Business Development Manager” can describe very different jobs. In one business it means building a territory from scratch. In another it means converting warm enquiries. Elsewhere it may be closer to account growth, channel development or major-project pursuit.

Before writing the advertisement or beginning interviews, define what the person will actually need to do to create revenue.

BDM or Account Manager? If most of the role is protecting and growing existing customers, you may not need a pure new-business BDM.

That role may align more closely with an Account Manager profile.

Market Who are they selling to?

Define customer type, decision makers, segments and whether entirely new relationships need to be opened.

Pipeline Where will opportunities come from?

Determine how much pipeline is self-generated versus inbound, referrals or existing relationships.

Sales Cycle How does a sale progress?

Consider complexity, stakeholders, sales-cycle length, quoting, tenders and internal support.

Performance What will success look like?

Define activity, qualified pipeline, conversion, revenue, margin and territory expectations.

02 · Build The Success Profile

Define what the person must be able to prove.

Years of experience and industry background are useful context, but a stronger hiring brief translates the commercial objective into observable sales capability.

01
Prospecting

Can they consistently create conversations with relevant prospects?

02
Pipeline Creation

Can activity become genuine qualified opportunity rather than CRM volume?

03
Qualification

Can they test need, fit, timing and likelihood to proceed?

04
Discovery

Can they uncover the commercial problem rather than immediately pitch?

05
Opportunity Progression

Can they maintain next-step discipline and keep genuine opportunities moving?

06
Closing

Can they ask for commitment and convert appropriately qualified opportunities?

07
Commercial Discipline

Can they balance growth with margin, deal quality and realistic forecasting?

03 · Validate The Track Record

Separate sales results from the environment that produced them.

Strong numbers on paper matter, but you need to establish how those results were created and whether the same capability is transferable to your business.

What you may hear
What you need to establish
“Managed a $2 million sales portfolio.”
Was the revenue inherited, retained, grown or personally won from entirely new customers?
“Exceeded sales target.”
What was the target, what pipeline already existed and how much opportunity did the candidate personally create?
“Strong relationship builder.”
Were these inherited customer relationships or relationships the candidate personally opened and developed?
“Generated new business.”
How were prospects identified, approached, qualified and converted into genuine opportunities?
“Managed the full sales cycle.”
Which stages did they personally control and where did management, technical or pre-sales support become involved?

A $2 million inherited portfolio tells you something very different from $2 million of new revenue created through self-generated prospecting.

04 · Interview For Evidence

Ask questions that make the candidate show you how they sell.

Ask for specific examples, then drill into what the candidate personally did, why they did it and what happened next.

QUESTION 01 “Tell me about a new customer you won from a cold start.”

Probe target selection, first contact, discovery, stakeholders, objections and close.

QUESTION 02 “How did you build pipeline when there were not enough leads?”

Look for a real prospecting method rather than broad statements about networking.

QUESTION 03 “Tell me about a deal you chose not to pursue.”

This can reveal qualification discipline and commercial judgement.

QUESTION 04 “Walk me through the last significant deal you won.”

Clarify personal contribution from initial opportunity through to commitment.

QUESTION 05 “What does a healthy pipeline look like to you?”

Test their understanding of genuine stages, conversion and next actions.

QUESTION 06 “What would you do in your first 90 days here?”

Listen for learning, target planning, activity and realistic pipeline development.

05 · Screen Beyond The CV

Build a broader body of evidence before the final interview.

CVs establish career history, but they do not show how someone will respond to the commercial situations your BDM role will create.

Relevant screening can explore prospecting, qualification, opportunity judgement, customer scenarios, autonomy, pace, motivation and other role-specific areas.

How We Assess Sales Talent
Sales Channel Solutions Bespoke sales screening tailored to the specific role and industry.
01 Tailor

Build screening around the actual sales environment.

02 Complete

Progressed candidates complete screening before presentation.

03 Assess

Review evidence, strengths and potential areas of risk.

04 Interview

Use the findings to identify areas requiring deeper validation.

06 · Common Hiring Mistakes

Where BDM hiring decisions often go wrong.

Poor appointments often come from confusing interview confidence, industry familiarity or previous revenue responsibility with evidence of new-business capability.

01
Hiring the best interviewer

Presentation skills alone do not prove prospecting discipline or sales process.

02
Overweighting industry experience

Industry familiarity should not automatically outweigh stronger selling capability.

03
Confusing account growth with new business

Growing existing revenue is different from creating new customer relationships.

04
Ignoring pipeline source

Someone accustomed to inbound demand may struggle when opportunity must be created.

05
Using vague success measures

Without defined outcomes, candidates cannot be assessed consistently.

06
Expecting instant revenue

Longer sales cycles often show early progress through pipeline before revenue.

07 · Commercial Offer

Align the incentive structure with the behaviour you want.

The compensation model should make sense for the sales cycle, margin profile and the level of control the BDM has over the result.

Base salary and realistic OTE
When commission becomes earned
Revenue versus margin weighting
Lead and marketing support
Territory and account ownership
First 90 Days

Define what good early performance should look like.

The exact milestones should reflect your sales cycle rather than expecting every BDM to deliver revenue immediately.

30 Days Learn the Market

Product, customers, CRM, process, proposition and priority segments.

60 Days Build Activity

Prospecting rhythm, target plans, meetings and early opportunities.

90 Days Establish Pipeline

Qualified opportunities, next steps and early commercial momentum.

08 · Make The Hiring Decision

Compare candidates against the role, not against each other.

One of the easiest ways to lose discipline late in a search is to ask, “Which candidate did we like most?” A stronger question is, “Which candidate gives us the best evidence against the success profile we defined?”

Bring the decision back to the market, customer, pipeline source, sales cycle, autonomy, prospecting requirement and commercial expectations of the role.

Hiring Principle The strongest candidate is not necessarily the strongest CV. It is the person with the strongest evidence of succeeding in the sales environment you actually need them to enter.
Need Help With The Search? Sales Channel Solutions recruits Business Development Managers across NSW.

Our process combines active and passive candidate search, sales-specific recruiter screening and bespoke candidate assessment. Explore BDM Recruitment →

Blake Shields, Director of Sales Channel Solutions
About The Author

Blake Shields · Director, Sales Channel Solutions

Blake brings more than 20 years of experience across frontline sales, sales leadership and General Management. Sales Channel Solutions uses that commercial experience to help employers define sales roles around the customer, market, sales cycle and performance expectations behind the job title.

Frequently Asked Questions

Hiring a Business Development Manager

Questions employers commonly need to resolve before taking a BDM role to market.

What should I look for when hiring a Business Development Manager?

Look for evidence that matches your actual sales environment: prospecting, self-generated pipeline, qualification, discovery, opportunity progression, closing and commercial discipline.

Should a BDM have experience in the same industry?

Industry experience can be valuable, particularly in technical or relationship-driven markets, but it should be weighed alongside evidence of the selling capability required.

What is the difference between a BDM and an Account Manager?

A BDM is generally more focused on creating new business, opening relationships and building pipeline. An Account Manager is usually more focused on retaining and growing an existing customer base.

How do you assess whether a candidate can prospect?

Ask for specific examples of how they identified targets, created first conversations, maintained activity and converted that activity into qualified pipeline.

How long should a new BDM take to perform?

It depends on the sales cycle, market, lead support and complexity of the offer. Early measures may include activity, meetings, qualified opportunities and pipeline progression before revenue.

Can Sales Channel Solutions recruit a BDM for our business?

Yes. Sales Channel Solutions supports Business Development Manager recruitment across Sydney, the Central Coast, Newcastle, Lake Macquarie, the Hunter Region and selected wider NSW markets.

Your Next BDM Hire

Need someone who can create pipeline, not just inherit it?

Tell us about the market, sales cycle and new-business outcome you need. We can help define the search and reach both active and passive BDM talent across NSW.

Leave a Reply